| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 1 | Ike | Luke Donald | Posted by Gabes | |
| 2 | Fox | Webb Simpson | ho ho ho | |
| 3 | Gabes | Tiger Woods | Hate him. Big Time! Only thing I'd hate more though is letting him slip to somebody else and watching him rebound in 2012. If he does, it will be for the ForeSkins! | |
| 4 | Jack | Matt Kuchar | Jack says Gabes is a no good beat off!! Posted by Sobo | |
| 5 | Sobo | Dustin Johnson | Play it again, Dustin! | |
| 6 | Willo | Bill Haas | I do not do, I review. A mgmt principle. | |
| 7 | Al | Jason Day | Tons of upside, a rising star. Hopefully a true breakout year. | |
| 8 | Hans | Rory McIlroy | sorry Andy, I couldnt pass up Rory | |
| 9 | Andy | Nick Watney | Don't blame you, Hans. Gotta love him for Majors. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 10 | Andy | Bubba Watson | This way I won't have to worry about whether it's "Watney" or "Watson" that I have on my team. | |
| 11 | Hans | Adam Scott | lots of talent in this pool. didnt think Scott would drop to the 2nd round! | |
| 12 | Al | Phil Mickelson | Sentimental favorite. I may regret it in the end, but I like rooting for him, so I may as well have him on the team | |
| 13 | Willo | K.J. Choi | Posted by Gabes | |
| 14 | Sobo | Rickie Fowler | Getting the band back together.... | |
| 15 | Jack | Justin Rose | Posted by Gabes | |
| 16 | Gabes | Charl Schwartzel | Wanted this guy bad! Got him! | |
| 17 | Fox | Steve Stricker | Back from party .. roll the dice ... | |
| 18 | Ike | Hunter Mahan | Very hot girlfriend! Really don't give shit how he plays as long as he hangs with her... |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 19 | Ike | Lee Westwood | ||
| 20 | Fox | Keegan Bradley | Good morning all. | |
| 21 | Gabes | Gary Woodland | Bombs away!! | |
| 22 | Jack | Brandt Snedeker | Posted by Gabes | |
| 23 | Sobo | Aaron Baddeley | Risk-reward pick. Will call Willo now | |
| 24 | Willo | Charles Howell III | Posted by Gabes | |
| 25 | Al | Geoff Ogilvy | Al gets hosed on Bradley and Baddeley but grabs the lanky Aussie with pick #25. | |
| 26 | Hans | David Toms | an old guy at 45 | |
| 27 | Andy | Fredrik Jacobson |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 28 | Andy | Anthony Kim | Taking a leap here. don't really like the guy, but I think he has upside. we'll see. | |
| 29 | Hans | Bo Van Pelt | taking a flyer here | |
| 30 | Al | Rory Sabbatini | posted by Sobo | |
| 31 | Willo | Mark Wilson | Him. Whoever he is. Is the man. | |
| 32 | Sobo | Brendan Steele | Heading out to dinner; back on line by 10 pm | |
| 33 | Jack | Kevin Na | Posted by Gabes | |
| 34 | Gabes | Jim Furyk | Loved him at the President's Cup when he went 5-0. Had him when he won the FedEx Cup in 2010. He should not be still on the board near the end of the fourth round! | |
| 35 | Fox | Sergio Garcia | Agree with you Gabes .. I was watching with disbelief as my hometown boy inched closer and closer to me but then AAARRRGGHHHHHH snaked! So I'll take the Spanish guy. | |
| 36 | Ike | Zach Johnson | Finished '11 strong...we'll see if it carries into '12... |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 37 | Ike | Jeff Overton | Finished '11 strong...we'll see if it carries into '12... | |
| 38 | Fox | Bryce Molder | Finished '11 strong...we'll see if it carries into '12... | |
| 39 | Gabes | Martin Laird | ||
| 40 | Jack | Camilo Villegas | posted by Hans | |
| 41 | Sobo | Bud Cauley | Maybe a bit early, but upside is huge. Didn't see him making it back to me. G'night mates! | |
| 42 | Willo | Spencer Levin | Posted by Al as per Willo direction. | |
| 43 | Al | Carl Pettersson | Nothing pithy to say.... just a legacy Dimpled Ball, blue collar type who makes cuts, plays 25 + tourneys | |
| 44 | Hans | Robert Karlsson | ||
| 45 | Andy | Martin Kaymer | Posted by Gabes |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 46 | Andy | Ian Poulter | Posted by Gabes | |
| 47 | Hans | Y.E. Yang | a former Ace Hole returns | |
| 48 | Al | Trevor Immelman | Healthy again, only 32. Betting on a bounce back season | |
| 49 | Willo | Jason Dufner | Posted by Al. I might have taken him instead of Immelmann except that was the second of two picks that Willo had given me last round. Did not want to seem like I was stealing his pick and it allowed me to keep this rolling without having to track him down for his next choice. | |
| 50 | Sobo | Scott Stallings | Apologize to anyone who got a strange message from me early this am- my email must have been hacked. | |
| 51 | Jack | Jonathan Byrd | 17 of 26 cuts made last year is about where we are. Back to the pool. | |
| 52 | Gabes | Kyle Stanley | ||
| 53 | Fox | Chris Kirk | Beam me up! | |
| 54 | Ike | Ryan Moore |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 55 | Ike | John Senden | ||
| 56 | Fox | Jhonattan Vegas | Needed a South American | |
| 57 | Gabes | Ben Crane | ||
| 58 | Jack | Steve Marino | Pretty consistent year on year | |
| 59 | Sobo | Sean OHair | welcome back to a former Pinseeker! | |
| 60 | Willo | Ernie Els | His return to superbness. Yes. | |
| 61 | Al | Vijay Singh | I had Sean O'hair in my sights. good pick Sobo. But as long as Willo is going to head down memory lane w Ernie looking for one more year of glory, then I'll do him one better w Vijay | |
| 62 | Hans | Cameron Tringale | plays alot.... we'll see | |
| 63 | Andy | Tommy Gainey | Unexpected company and internet connection issues. Sorry. Gainey off the board. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 64 | Andy | Padraig Harrington | Screw it. I'll take the Irishman and look for a bounce. | |
| 65 | Hans | Brendon de Jonge | sorry for the delay. i had sent this pick to Al 3 hrs ago. maybe it upset him | |
| 66 | Al | Robert Allenby | For old times sakes.... A legacy Dimpled Ball from a few years ago. If he sinks a few putts he can be dangerous. Kinda like me. | |
| 67 | Willo | Lucas Glover | An exceptional pick. | |
| 68 | Sobo | Chez Reavie | Snaked by Willo- bastard! | |
| 69 | Jack | Charley Hoffman | Posted by Gabes | |
| 70 | Gabes | Ryan Palmer | ||
| 71 | Fox | Scott Piercy | Sorry for the short delay .. was out .. this is tougher this year almost seems like we are drafting more players as a group .. | |
| 72 | Ike | Seung-yul Noh | Time to take a flyer on somebody... |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 73 | Ike | Louis Oosthuizen | Hoping for a bounce back year with 15+ PGA events... | |
| 74 | Fox | Jerry Kelly | ||
| 75 | Gabes | Kevin Chappell | I'll roll the bones on an up and comer. Finished tied for third as a rookie this year at the U.S. Open, and he has a ticket for Augusta. | |
| 76 | Jack | Robert Garrigus | Back to the Smoothies | |
| 77 | Sobo | D.A. Points | Go IRISH!! | |
| 78 | Willo | George McNeill | Another steal in this draft. Thx Sobo. | |
| 79 | Al | Harris English | I have enough old dudes. Time for a young rookie | |
| 80 | Hans | Ricky Barnes | ||
| 81 | Andy | John Rollins | moving right along .. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 82 | Andy | Billy Hurley | Go ahead. Which one of you commies is going to say something about my boy? He's golf's answer to Tim Tebow. | |
| 83 | Hans | Kevin Streelman | posted by fox | |
| 84 | Al | Andres Romero | He was a DB before I cut him for J Vegas... Andres gets a second... and final... chance to stay on the big team | |
| 85 | Willo | Chad Campbell | Albert stuck it up my arse very similar to what Fla. State did to the Irish. And it hurts!! | |
| 86 | Sobo | JJ Killeen | Willo- 1) nice pick, and 2) GO FUCK YOURSELF! This is two times in a row! STOP IT!! | |
| 87 | Jack | Brandt Jobe | ||
| 88 | Gabes | Brian Davis | It's ham and egg time, and this guy loves to eat breakfast. | |
| 89 | Fox | Paul Casey | Snaked by Gabes, Willo so I am taking Casey two months two soon. | |
| 90 | Ike | Danny Lee |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 91 | Ike | Sang-moon Bae | ||
| 92 | Fox | J.B. Holmes | ||
| 93 | Gabes | Greg Chalmers | ||
| 94 | Jack | Graeme McDowell | Hoping for a comeback season in the Tampa Airport! Liked J.B. Holmes before his brain surgery! | |
| 95 | Sobo | Chris Stroud | ||
| 96 | Willo | Retief Goosen | The older the better is my motto. | |
| 97 | Al | Johnson Wagner | Local product. On the fringes of being good. Did make it to the winner's circle once last year in a second rate event | |
| 98 | Hans | Hunter Haas | I had Bill last year. 2012 will be his 'cousin' Hunter. we'll see.... | |
| 99 | Andy | Paul Goydos | He was at the top of my list. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 100 | Andy | Kris Blanks | He was next on my list. | |
| 101 | Hans | Jimmy Walker | Good Times! | |
| 102 | Al | Harrison Frazar | He plays at Kapalua | |
| 103 | Willo | Pat Perez | posted by Al | |
| 104 | Sobo | Stewart Cink | One of the good guys in golf- hopefully has a rebound year. Happy New Year to all!! | |
| 105 | Jack | Nick OHern | Pacers 3-0 | |
| 106 | Gabes | Blake Adams | 34 starts--made 23 cuts--6 top 25s--4 top 10s--1 third place finish--round 12. White toast and hash browns with the ham and eggs, please! | |
| 107 | Fox | Josh Teater | 30 starts--made 21 cuts INCLUDING his last 10 -- 7 top 25s -- round 12 after that douche bag golfer Gabes took ... bwaaaaaaa ha ha I'll have the steak and eggs, wheat bread lightly toasted with a side of kick butt. Ikey, put this puppy to rest. Good night, God bless. | |
| 108 | Ike | Francesco Molinari |