| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 1 | Gabes | Tiger Woods | And so it begins again! | |
| 2 | Sobo | Dustin Johnson | Posted by Gabes! | |
| 3 | Fox | Matt Kuchar | Never heard of him. | |
| 4 | Hans | Jim Furyk | not long and flashy, but very reliable. | |
| 5 | Ike | Anthony Kim | Love the belt! Hope his thumb is okay. | |
| 6 | Jack | Steve Stricker | First time as a Smoothie. | |
| 7 | Al | Phil Mickelson | Wow, how the mighty have fallen... Phil the Thrill makes it to #7 slot. | |
| 8 | Andy | Luke Donald | Why not. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 9 | Andy | Nick Watney | Why? | |
| 10 | Al | Camilo Villegas | ...becuae I love saying "bee-jay-gus" | |
| 11 | Jack | Ernie Els | Back on track and still young in his early 40s! | |
| 12 | Ike | Tim Clark | ||
| 13 | Hans | Jeff Overton | ||
| 14 | Fox | Zach Johnson | the weather outside is dreary, the fox is getting beery ... | |
| 15 | Sobo | Rickie Fowler | Man Crush, Act II | |
| 16 | Gabes | Hunter Mahan |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 17 | Gabes | Justin Rose | ||
| 18 | Sobo | Jason Day | Would have taken either Mahan or Rose, but this works, too. | |
| 19 | Fox | Paul Casey | ||
| 20 | Hans | Lee Westwood | World's #1 | |
| 21 | Ike | Ryan Moore | ||
| 22 | Jack | Bo Van Pelt | A Richmond Indiana boy with 8 top tens last year! | |
| 23 | Al | Geoff Ogilvy | Slipped after a solid start lasy year, I expect a bounce back | |
| 24 | Andy | Retief Goosen | Look for a Grand Slam |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 25 | Andy | Bubba Watson | The NEW Lefty on tour | |
| 26 | Al | Adam Scott | Young, had a bounceback year in 2009, lots of upside | |
| 27 | Jack | Rory McIlroy | Another first time Smoothie!! | |
| 28 | Ike | Ian Poulter | Multiple snakes. This guy will win a major this year! | |
| 29 | Hans | Graeme McDowell | Reigning US Open champion. Will play PGA tour in 2011 | |
| 30 | Fox | Sean O'Hair | ||
| 31 | Sobo | Ben Crane | Welcome back to a former Seeker | |
| 32 | Gabes | Robert Allenby |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 33 | Gabes | Padraig Harrington | ||
| 34 | Sobo | Ryan Palmer | A Nicklaus may be next..... | |
| 35 | Fox | K.J. Choi | ||
| 36 | Hans | Bill Haas | ||
| 37 | Ike | Martin Kaymer | ||
| 38 | Jack | Ricky Barnes | Sorry for the delay. Kids still home - Italian restaurant last night - too much vino rosso | |
| 39 | Al | Martin Laird | Posted by Gabes | |
| 40 | Andy | Kevin Na |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 41 | Andy | Steve Marino | ||
| 42 | Al | Carl Pettersson | Posted by Gabes | |
| 43 | Jack | J.B. Holmes | Welcome Home Holmes. Had him when he won for the first time in Phoenix. | |
| 44 | Ike | Charley Hoffman | Talking to Jack as I make this pick. Multi-tasking at its best! | |
| 45 | Hans | Stewart Cink | ||
| 46 | Fox | Heath Slocum | ||
| 47 | Sobo | Marc Leishman | ||
| 48 | Gabes | D.J. Trahan | At the Halfway House; Time for a cold one! |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 49 | Gabes | Charles Howell III | And we head for home! | |
| 50 | Sobo | Robert Karlsson | ||
| 51 | Fox | David Toms | ||
| 52 | Hans | Brendon de Jonge | he sure will play often - hopefully well | |
| 53 | Ike | Brandt Snedeker | Snaked AGAIN by Hans! (although it is the 7th round...) | |
| 54 | Jack | Vaughn Taylor | Roanoke Virginia boy who had 6 top tens last year. Another Smoothie Rookie | |
| 55 | Al | Lucas Glover | Looking for bounce back to US Open Championship form of 2008. Am I dreaming? | |
| 56 | Andy | Ryuji Imada |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 57 | Andy | John Senden | I read where he should have a good year. | |
| 58 | Al | Rory Sabbatini | A multi-year Dimpled Ball is welcomed back. The man voted the person other PGA players would least like to play with is welcome on my team. I think Phil was #2, so I am cornering the market. | |
| 59 | Jack | Jason Bohn | ||
| 60 | Ike | John Rollins | Home-grown in Richmond, now a transplanted Texan. | |
| 61 | Hans | Charl Schwartzel | next great player from South Africa. supposed to play 15 tournaments | |
| 62 | Fox | Jonathan Byrd | ||
| 63 | Sobo | Jamie Lovemark | I think it's about time..... | |
| 64 | Gabes | Louis Oosthuizen |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 65 | Gabes | Charlie Wi | ||
| 66 | Sobo | Stuart Appleby | G'night, mates! | |
| 67 | Fox | Kevin Streelman | ||
| 68 | Hans | Spencer Levin | Mornin' boys! How bout them Vikings | |
| 69 | Ike | Vijay Singh | ||
| 70 | Jack | Cameron Beckman | ||
| 71 | Al | Webb Simpson | DB alum | |
| 72 | Andy | Fredrik Jacobson | Can't believe he's still here |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 73 | Andy | Kevin Kisner | Was going to take Jacobson, but Andy snaked me | |
| 74 | Al | Andres Romero | Fot a little ethnicity | |
| 75 | Jack | Robert Garrigus | Doesn't hit it as far as I do (he's at 315 avg.) but young and three top threes last year. | |
| 76 | Ike | Arjun Atwal | ||
| 77 | Hans | Michael Sim | Ike - you got me on Atwal. I would have taken the Indian. settling for the Aussie | |
| 78 | Fox | Henrik Stenson | Also intended to pick Atwal. Maybe he will be terrible. One can always hope. Oh, and good luck with him Ike. | |
| 79 | Sobo | Jerry Kelly | ||
| 80 | Gabes | Pat Perez |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 81 | Gabes | Graham DeLaet | ||
| 82 | Sobo | Sergio Garcia | ||
| 83 | Fox | Y.E. Yang | I swear, half hour ago I looked this over and thought, well it is time to take Sergio so I will do that except Sobo probably will ... | |
| 84 | Hans | Justin Leonard | come back year, I hope | |
| 85 | Ike | Chad Campbell | Sorry for the delay...just back from weekly Cancer Conference. Remember when Chad Campbell went in the early rounds? | |
| 86 | Jack | Angel Cabrera | Posted by Gabes | |
| 87 | Al | Bryce Molder | Running out of pithy comments | |
| 88 | Andy | David Duval | Posted by Gabes |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 89 | Andy | Rocco Mediate | Posted by Gabes | |
| 90 | Al | Aaron Baddeley | Only 29, has been a winner. Is he poised for a return to prominence? Only if he wants it Baddeley enough. | |
| 91 | Jack | Jason Dufner | Done in record time!!!!!!!!!!! Thanks Aunt Bee for moving us along!! | |
| 92 | Ike | Matt Jones | ||
| 93 | Hans | Chris Kirk | taking a flier on a Nationwide star we'll see | |
| 94 | Fox | Nick O'Hern | This is Nick OHern. Stupid apostraphe's. Oh .. and he is going to rock it this year. | |
| 95 | Sobo | Trevor Immelman | Bring it home CA! | |
| 96 | Gabes | Brian Gay | And so it ends! |